Comments on: More on Velvet Elvis

By: Phillip

Phillip — Tue, 04 Sep 2007 03:04:15 +0000

I haven’t read VE, but I did read Blue Like Jazz. I enjoyed it. Not because of its depth, but because of its light-heartedness (is that a word). It did a great job of exhorting me to reach out to people who most Christians overlook or worse, avoid. Mostly, I just enjoyed BLJ because of how much fun it was to read. Miller has a great sense of humor.

By: Jeff

Jeff — Fri, 31 Aug 2007 22:38:44 +0000

Overall, I thought Blue Like Jazz was much better. Donald Miller doesn’t write in a way that is prescriptive for the church but in a narrative fashion in BLJ that ends up simply being descriptive of his own church experiences. He does make observations throughout, but they arise from his own experiences.

Bell, on the other hand, wears the moniker of a pastor/teacher and so what he writes is done from the perspective of someone who, I feel, should be more diligent in being truthful. Some of his sources are unverifiable and really questionable.

Both books, however, should not be taken too seriously. While I really enjoyed BLJ, it won’t go on my shelf of all-time favorites. I don’t think either book adds anything significant to our knowing Jesus Christ better. Rather, they make attempts at trying to understand how to minister more effectively.

BTW, I haven’t read Sex God, but the very title and its brazen attempt to sell copies turns me off. I doubt I’ll read anything by Bell again. I have so much I’d like to read that when an author disappoints me, I move on pretty quickly. Bell has a following, but I’m not one of them.

By: Amy Ables Lawson

Amy Ables Lawson — Fri, 31 Aug 2007 20:30:25 +0000

I was wondering if this book was worth all the hype it has received.

Would it fall under the same category as BLUE LIKE JAZZ?

I’d thought about picking it up just to see why I keep see it popping up places but I have a huge pile of books that I KNOW I really want to read before I start reading “maybe” books.

By: Josh R

Josh R — Fri, 31 Aug 2007 15:17:23 +0000

I haven’t read VE, but I listened to quite a few of Bell’s sermons a few months ago… I found his teaching to be thought provoking and interesting, but quite Berean-proof.

Sometimes I think he uses historical traditions that are difficult to verify to stretch the meaning of the Biblical text to fit his agenda.

There is a popular radio preacher here in town, Chuck Missler, who is also Berean-proof. He spits out hundreds of historical facts to support their argument, but it is very difficult to verify all of those facts. When I have tried, there is often some controversy. These preachers both have become very popular because they seem to be so brainy.

Some folks that I highly respect say that “Sex God” is a much better book.

By: lindy

lindy — Fri, 31 Aug 2007 14:52:51 +0000

Have you read Sex God by Bell yet?? I haven’t read Velvet Elvis… but I’m kind of liking Sex God (despite the fact he probably named it that for controversy).