Review: Charlie Bone, Midnight for Charlie Bone (rated 3 stars)
If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
Midnight For Charlie Bone (Children of the Red King)
by Jenny Nimmo
I have seen these Charlie Bone books occupying bookshelves for a few years now. I heard they were disappointingly similar to the Harry Potter books. Since I’ve completed the Potter series, I decided to give the first one a try.
A young boy discovers he has magical powers. His discovery produces family conflict. He is sent to a school for other kids with magical powers where he engages in heroic deeds and brings the book’s plot to a satisfying conclusion. Nope, it wasn’t Harry. Neither was Hogwarts the destination. Try Charlie and Bloor’s Academy.
After completing the book, I had one of those senses of strange verified entitlement. Everything I’d heard was true. After book 1, the CB series is a knockoff of the success of the HP series. It’s rare that such rumors and cultural whisper prove true.
Yet… I found myself engaged in the fresh storyline, and before book’s end, I had chuckled a few times and become engaged with this new cast of characters, plot twists and personalities.
I’ve ordered book 2… off of the used list at Amazon. (Local library didn’t have 1 or 2). I’m willing to give this series another chance in the second book.
See more about Midnight For Charlie Bone (Children of the Red King)
March 26th, 2008 at 9:04 pm
I wonder if the woman who accused J.K. Rowling of “stealing her stories” when the Harry Potter came out is the one who wrote these books.